Saturday, March 19. 2005Ideological absolutism and Terry SchiavoFrancis Porretto writes about Terry Schiavo:
Let's be perfectly candid about what Michael Schiavo intends for his helpless wife: he wants her dead. His claim that she would want the same is hopelessly tainted by his pecuniary interest in her demise. He insists on killing her even though the sole legal way to get her into her coffin is to subject her to two weeks of excruciating torment. To tell you the truth, I'm actually more sympathetic to her husband than to the pro-death activists and the judge. He's killing her for money (and also possibly to cover up evidence of previous crimes). This is an exaggerated form of the sort of base evil to which all of us are occasionally tempted (although thankfully the overwhelming majority of us have the moral strength to resist). It is profoundly evil, but it is nevertheless comprehensible. I can see myself in his shoes, although I pray I'd never make his choices, no matter the circumstances. But to torture this woman (and forced starvation constitutes torture by any recognized definition of the word...even on the Left) purely for the advancement of an abstract principle about the right to die, as the judge and the pro-death activists are doing, is a truly incomprehensible abomination. It is indeed an echo of the abortion debate, where the issue is so fiercely polarized that pro-choice forces are finding themselves arguing that there's no moral difference between expelling a microscopic clump of cells and killing a viable infant in mid-birth, but that there is a difference between killing the infant during birth and killing it immediately afterward. In service to their ideology they've entirely sacrificed both reason and humanity. Compared to that, a man who wants to kill his wife for money is easy to sympathize with. Short of a patient who's sitting up in bed screaming and begging for her life, there really aren't any worse example cases for the pro-euthanasia argument than this one. Mr. Porretto and I differ in our beliefs about abortion and euthanasia. I believe there are circumstances in which both are acceptable in a least-of-all-available-wrongs sense, whereas he, as I understand his beliefs, does not accept any set of circumstances in which either would be an acceptable choice. I can respect that...especially since my moral views are far closer to his than my pro-choice stand would imply. But only someone so fanatical about their ideology that they're incapable of true thought or feeling would think that the Terry Schiavo case is anything but an argument against sanctioned euthanasia...and a compelling one at that. Watching pro-euthanasia forces on the wrong side of Terry Schiavo may well turn me against euthanasia, just as watching pro-choice activists fight for "partial birth abortion" has all but completely turned me against abortion. Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)
My, what an effective use of "~damning by faint praise~" rhetoric.
I've quit listening to ANYthing the Corrupted Left has to say on the subject of this tragedy. The only cogent observation that matters is that all the active participants in this senseless murder are ...ALL ...Evil. I refuse to credit ANY "intellectual justification" on the subject with anything other then a "You're evil" retort. The judge ...is evil. The attorney ...is evil. The husband ...is evil. The justifiers ...are evil. The political and social system and philosophical worldview that would allow this to happen ...is being eaten ...by evil. Nothing else about this vile drama is intellectually necessary, beyond observation of the manifestation of pure evil displayed throughout by the particants in this Corruption. God help us all. Short of a patient who's sitting up in bed screaming and begging for her life, there really aren't any worse example cases for the pro-euthanasia argument than this one.
There was a report that when she was told what was about to happen, she started to cry and could not be quieted. If that's true, we're already at the worst case. The author does not allow comments to this entry
|
Excerpt: The Lonely Lib/Con reviews the case of Terri Schiavo, and sees another issue in its shadow: It is indeed an echo of the abortion debate, where the issue is so...
Tracked: Mar 19, 08:56